ProtonMail vs ShieldBox
for Healthcare Providers
in Australia
Healthcare providers face the strictest email compliance obligations in Australia. See why medical practices are switching from ProtonMail to ShieldBox for Privacy Act and My Health Records Act compliance.
ProtonMail is excellent for privacy-conscious individuals but Swiss law is not Australian law. APP 8 obligations require Australian jurisdiction. No ASD Essential Eight alignment, no AI features, and no Australian support team.
Key Risks for Healthcare Providers
Using ProtonMail
Compliance Obligations for Healthcare Providers
Why ProtonMail cannot satisfy the compliance requirements of Australian healthcare providers.
All healthcare providers regardless of size must comply with the Privacy Act 1988. ProtonMail stores email on Switzerland servers — creating ongoing APP 8 cross-border disclosure obligations for every patient email.
Registered healthcare providers have specific obligations around MHR data in email. ProtonMail's offshore storage creates unauthorised access risk under the Act.
Healthcare is the highest-reporting NDB sector. ProtonMail does not provide the breach detection and 30-day OAIC notification workflow that Australian healthcare providers need.
AHPRA-registered practitioners have professional obligations to protect patient confidentiality. Offshore email creates a structural confidentiality risk that cannot be mitigated contractually.
Why ShieldBox Wins for Healthcare Providers
ShieldBox is the only email platform that satisfies all three layers of Australian healthcare email compliance: Privacy Act 1988, My Health Records Act 2012, and AHPRA professional standards.
ProtonMail vs ShieldBox for Healthcare Providers — FAQs
Can I use ProtonMail for my Australian medical practice?
No. ProtonMail stores email on Switzerland servers, creating ongoing APP 8 cross-border disclosure obligations for every patient email. The My Health Records Act 2012 also creates specific risks when clinical data is stored offshore. ShieldBox's Australian-hosted email eliminates both risks.
Is ProtonMail compliant with the My Health Records Act 2012?
No. ProtonMail stores email on Switzerland servers. The My Health Records Act 2012 creates specific obligations for registered healthcare providers around MHR data in email — offshore storage creates unauthorised access risk under the Act.
What email retention period applies to Australian healthcare providers?
State health records legislation requires clinical records to be retained for 7 years from the date of last contact. For patients who were minors, records must be retained until the patient turns 25 or 7 years from last contact, whichever is later. ShieldBox's 7-year archive satisfies this — ProtonMail does not provide equivalent Australian-hosted archiving.
Why are Australian healthcare providers switching from ProtonMail to ShieldBox?
Australian healthcare providers are switching from ProtonMail to ShieldBox to eliminate APP 8 cross-border disclosure obligations, satisfy My Health Records Act requirements, and meet AHPRA professional conduct obligations. ShieldBox is the only email platform built specifically for Australian healthcare compliance.
Switch from ProtonMail to ShieldBox
Start for free — no credit card, no US servers, no CLOUD Act exposure. Built for Australian healthcare providers.